Is it just me that can see the English national team struggling in the future? Sure we’ve got the odd ‘superstar’ coming through the ranks when you look at Jack Wilshire and Oxlade Chamberlain but its doubtful even these players will be able to compete with the level of quality that will be on the international stage in a few years time.
Who’s to blame for this? In my eyes English clubs are due to their scouting and youth recruitment. It is so easy to fall through the scouting net in England and here’s why…
The competitive nature of finding the next “world beater” results in player’s potential ability getting overlooked. Scouts, even right from a young age look at outstanding strength or speed and ignore the technical aspects of the game believing they can be coached.
This is due to whether they will admit it or not everything being results driven. Coaches want players who can make an impact immediately, not players who will need time to develop. If a club see a decent player but have 3 or 4 players in the same position as him won’t give him the time of day. What’s worse is they won’t tip another club that could make use of him just incase he turns out to be that exceptional player.
English schoolboy football players, U7’s right through to U16’s should be able to concentrate on developing as players, expressing themselves and learning how to play the game properly. Instead it is drummed into them that losing is simply not good enough.
Clubs will take on and let go of thousands up on thousands of kids just for the 1 or 2 home-grown players a season that break into the clubs first team to join the wealth of international talent available to the first team manager for selection.
Comparing this to other nations, Spain for now, are the exact opposite to English clubs and have been successful because of it. They teach their players in the correct manor and results aren’t important to them. La Masia; Barcelona’s training camp for their youngsters, is iconic of this.
Although it will have no sudden impact, 10-15, maybe even 20 years down the line when the nation is breaking out with superstars all over the pitch it will have its benefits.
Freedom and expression can only have a positive impact on the future of the nation’s game. It’s not a myth that the kids in South-America will play till the sun goes down simply because of their passion for the game. This is encouraged and breeds confidence in them. Look at the amount of technically gifted players they produce as an outcome.
A country that has got took action about their scouting system and it is evident from their recent domination of the U17, U19 and U21 championships titles that have got it absolutely spot on are Germany.
Firstly, it is a regulation teams in the Bundesliga have to name 12 home-grown players in their matchday squad. In comparison to English teams who are only constrained by UEFA’s rules that they have to register eight in a 25-man squad. Some of them can even include foreign nationals if they’ve have been at the club’s academy for three years or more.
Secondly, it is an obligation that teams need to invest heavily in their youth set-ups or they will lose their memberships with the Bundesliga and not be able to compete. Accordingly, the number of German under-23-year olds playing regularly in the Bundesliga is 15% which has risen 9% since 2002.
This obviously has it’s affects with the teams finances too. They no longer need to splash out on over-priced talent from around the world like English clubs so often do and figures comparing to Premier League clubs are outstanding.
The Bundesliga makes £500 million less a year than the Premier League (Sponsors, T.V money etc) yet the 18 German clubs made a profit of £66 million more than the combined profit of the 20 clubs in the English top flight. In addition, the amount of debt owed between the clubs in the Bundesliga is a tiny £30 million, rather than the countless millions English clubs owe.
The Bundesliga reputation is increasing and German national team are a prime example of what can be achieved. Stars that have been born from this type of system are Mario Götze, Mesut Ozil, Toni Kroos, Thomas Muller, Sami Khedira, Rene Adler and Manuel Neuer to name just a few and they will provide a stern test for anyone on the world stage.
If English clubs don’t take action by introducting player regulations, investing in their youth and developing home-grown players with potential talent in aspects besides strength and speed the future could be bleak. I can see them getting left behind by other nations and a few miserable tournaments around the corner. The Brazil World Cup in 2014 could be a massive eye-opener.
Aaron Whittaker